Skip to content
openleonida
Get the weekly briefing
Jason, in a cap and a Leonida tank top, leans into a car window holding a pistol, with Lucia behind him in sunglasses and carrying a bag

GTA VI reviews: a 99 on Metacritic puts it at the top of the all-time list

openleonida newsroom · 4 min read

The verdict is in, and it's historic. GTA VI has a 99 on Metacritic from more than 150 critics on PS5, all of them positive, and sits at No. 1 on the site's all-time list. Critics praise Leonida, Jason and Lucia and the sheer level of detail; the complaints are about 30 fps, the controls and a story that drags late on. Here's what the reviews say.

GTA VI came out today, and the critics already had their verdict. The consensus is rare even for Rockstar: a 99 on Metacritic and on OpenCritic, and first place on Metacritic’s all-time list. We checked these figures on the afternoon of November 19, and they can still move as more reviews come in.

No. 1 on Metacritic’s all-time list

On Metacritic’s ranking of the best-reviewed games ever, GTA VI is now at the top. Its 99 ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, from 1998, and Metacritic’s tiebreak puts Rockstar’s game first. No other game released this century has a 99 there, and it’s also No. 1 of 2026.

It also beats Rockstar’s previous games: GTA IV has a 98, and GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 a 97.

According to an early count on November 18, around 80% of the scored PS5 reviews gave it a perfect score. The lowest score so far is an 80. On OpenCritic, it sits in the “Mighty” tier, the site’s highest.

What critics praise

The most repeated praise is for Leonida itself. Several reviews call it the best open world ever made, for its density and detail, with characters and police that react to what you do. Jason and Lucia’s relationship is the other big strength, and the driving, the visuals, the audio, the soundtrack and the variety of missions come up again and again.

The quotes give an idea of the tone. One review calls it “one of the best video games ever made.” Another describes “a monumental achievement in storytelling, immersion, gameplay, and breadth of content,” and one critic sums it up as “a game of opposites and awe, minute detail and impossible scale.”

What critics criticize

A 99 doesn’t mean there are no complaints. These are the most common:

  • 30 fps. The game is capped at 30 frames per second, with no performance mode, even on PS5 Pro. On base PS5 and on Xbox, the frame rate dips in dense areas.
  • Pacing. Some reviews find the opening slow, and others say the story drags in its later stretch. “The plot does begin to drag in its latter phases,” one notes.
  • Controls. One review warns that “a classic Rockstar problem is back: clunky controls,” especially when aiming and using the weapon wheel.
  • Missions. Enemies become bullet sponges late in the game, some missions fail for unclear reasons, and there’s no way to replay missions.
  • Languages. The voices are only in English, with no dubbing.

User reviews open tomorrow

Metacritic opens user reviews for GTA VI at 12 p.m. PST on November 20. Before launch, it had to remove fake user reviews and block new ones, as we covered in our launch eve roundup.

Our take

The 30 fps cap, the most debated detail before launch, is one of the recurring criticisms, and yet critics still called GTA VI a landmark. What matters most to us are the dips in dense areas on base consoles, because what we argued in our 30 fps analysis is that a stable 30 matters more than the number itself.

As for the story, at around 60 hours, according to reviews, a slower final stretch is hardly a surprise; the numbers are in how long GTA VI is.

Next stop: The Game Awards, where GTA VI already has eight nominations, Game of the Year among them. With these reviews, it arrives as the clear favorite. And if you’re just starting, everything about launch day is in GTA VI is out now.

  • Reviews
  • Metacritic
  • OpenCritic
  • Opinion
All news

Suggestions